Ken Roberts

I've done it a couple of times -- the "Classic" version through Bourg St Pierre -- but never the Grand Lui variation. The first time was with Sharon -- because back then the HR was the about the only ski tour in the Alps for which we could find English-language guidebook info. Even that time we did not start out intending to do the whole thing, and I had previously done two of the best sections as independent 1-2 day tours. I didn't want to do it a second time, but it was what the American partners I was with had heard of -- so I went along to be sociable -- and even that time most of us weren't intending to do whole thing.

Nowadays there's no excuse any more for savvy ski mountaineers to be "doing the Haute Route", because:

(a) you can "skim the cream" of the best sections by just doing separately the "Three Cols" tour in around 1-2 days (from Argentiere to Le Tour) plus Arolla to Zermatt in around 2-4 days.

(b) the esthetic of the traverse accomplishment is spoiled by putting a bus/taxi ride in the middle (except for the Grand Lui variation -- which few parties could expect to finish in a week).

(c) there's so much excellent information available in English about the many other great 1-2 day tours in the western Alps which are equally or more spectacular and/or have lots better skiing:

Vanoise Ski Touring, by Paul Henderson (Cicerone, 2002) www.cicerone.co.uk -- The title doesn't do it justice. I see it as a collection of many of the best ski tours in the northern French Alps outside of the Mont Blanc massif.

Mont-Blanc Ski Tours, by Eric Delaperriere and Franck Gentilini (Editions VAMOS, 2000) -- All the ski touring in the Mont Blanc massif. Translated from French.

(d) There's so many other great multi-day traverses (for those who need that sort of thing) with English-language guidebook info:

Alpine Ski Mountaineering volume 1: Western Alps, by Bill O'Connor (Cicerone, 2002) www.cicerone.co.uk -- and volume 2 for the Eastern Alps.

Since those two times I've done various Haute Route segments and variations again [ photos | more ] -- and I'll be glad to do those yet again -- but I cannot imagine ever again doing the whole thing.

[ This text is just to potentially fill up width space to help the browser format the left menucol better. You're not supposed to see it in your browser screen display or on your printed paper output. If you do see it or notice it, it shouldn't cause any problem with your use of this website. But you could let us know about how you experienced it. ]